I loved driving the 1500 - for the reasons stated, maneuverable, ride phenomenal, great hunting truck out west, wife could drive it, etc.
I took crap on the forum but when the 6.2 started having all the issues but I saw the writing on the wall with GM and I was out, flipped it (super glad I did now). I actually went with the 3.0 1500 first and if I went back to a 1500, I would still go back to that motor. We will see what they do in ‘27 but I’m reading DFM is back on the table for GM….which negates a gas option for me. I simply do not believe GM can get it right.
The 2500HD zr2 is the best driving HD from the factory -I’ve let guys drive it on the farm or on hunting trips and they all comment on how it handles, performs, etc
it’s big. I have an 06 and 16 Chevy HDs - parked beside each other it’s crazy how big these trucks are getting. unless you’re used to bigger HD trucks with some lift, it will take a bit to get comfortable. My wife won’t drive it. As stated, not nearly as easy to get around.
The payload though is where it shines - you can load SO much more for hunting, camping, whatever trips and it doesn’t sweat. If burdened down and pushing it, the 3.0 would drink DEF, payload maxes quicker than you think, handling degrades quicker, etc
I tow machinery, hay, and cattle for the farm as well and have been very happy with its performance.